An elegant vintage lakefront apartment living room with ivory upholstery, original plaster molding, oak floors and tall windows overlooking a gray-blue lake.

What East Lake Shore Drive's Co-op Sales Tell a Gold Coast Buyer

November 19, 2026

In June 2025, the 14th-floor co-op at 209 East Lake Shore Drive took one more price cut, to $7.9 million. The apartment is 12,000 square feet, made from two combined units, with interiors by architect Larry Booth. It had first come to market in August 2023 at just under $16 million. Three months after that last cut, on September 16, it went under contract, The Real Deal reported. In November 2025 it closed at $7.5 million, or $625 per square foot.

Jeff Lowe of our team represented the seller. "As soon as we got to our last asking price, we went under contract pretty quickly," he told The Real Deal. "So I think it's just a matter of getting to that right price."

That sale also fits a larger pattern. Over the past two years, the Gold Coast's best-known vintage co-ops have dropped a long way from their first asking prices, then closed close to their last ones, which makes the cuts a measure of how far those first prices sat from the market and the closings a reading of the market itself. For anyone looking at an East Lake Shore Drive or Astor Street co-op this winter, the closings are the numbers to start from.

Three closings on two blocks

Two of the three sales below are on East Lake Shore Drive and the third is a short walk north at 1500 North Lake Shore Drive. All three buildings date from 1913 to 1927.

Building Dates from Unit size First ask Closed Per sq ft
1500 N. Lake Shore Drive 1927 ~10,000 sq ft $13.5M, Feb. 2016 $4.5M, Jan. 2024 $450
199 E. Lake Shore Drive 1913 design 9,600 sq ft $11.5M, 2019 just under $4.9M, Mar. 2024 ~$510
209 E. Lake Shore Drive 1925 12,000 sq ft just under $16M, Aug. 2023 $7.5M, Nov. 2025 $625

The 1500 North Lake Shore Drive apartment is the one the Wrigley family owned for more than 50 years. It takes up the 14th floor and part of the 15th in the 23-story building New York architect Rosario Candela designed. According to The Real Deal's account of Crain's reporting, it came on and off the market for nearly eight years. It was asking $4.9 million in its final run and sold at $4.5 million. The 199 East Lake Shore Drive unit belonged to developer John Buck. His firm converted the Benjamin Marshall building to co-op ownership in 1996, and he sold his 21-room apartment for less than half its original ask, as Crain's reported in March 2024.

Across the three, the first asks were between $11.5 million and $16 million. The closing prices were between about $4.5 million and $7.5 million. In the two sales where the final ask was reported, the buyer paid within about 8 percent of it.

What the per-square-foot numbers separate

The headline price cuts treat these sales as one story. The per-square-foot figures split it in two.

All three closings fall between $450 and $625 a square foot. Every one of them is a very large, highly personal apartment. The Wrigley unit had been redone around a collection of 18th-century French paneled rooms, with a limestone staircase imported from France. The Farley apartment was a 6,000-square-foot unit bought in 1986 and joined to a second one in 1992. Very few buyers want 10,000 to 12,000 square feet built around someone else's taste, so those homes sold for what that small group of buyers would pay.

A smaller apartment in the same building as the Farley unit priced differently. In March 2025, the estate of philanthropist Ann Lurie listed her 5,700-square-foot co-op at 209 East Lake Shore Drive for $3.75 million, or $658 a square foot. It went on a private, agents-only listing site. The Real Deal reported that she had bought the unit for $1.7 million in 2020 and renovated it. Its three formal rooms run 63 feet along the Oak Street Beach side of the lakefront.

That $1.7 million purchase works out to about $298 a square foot in 2020. The 2025 asking price was more than double that, and higher per foot than any of the three trophy closings. The address was the same for both units. The size and the condition were different. On East Lake Shore Drive, the large discounts landed on the largest and most personalized apartments, while a smaller, renovated home in the same building was listed at more per foot than any of the three trophy units sold for.

The monthly figure that comes with the address

In a co-op, buyers purchase shares in the building rather than a deeded unit, and that means high monthly charges. When the Wrigley-family unit sold in January 2024, its monthly bill was $14,330. That cost goes into the same household budget as the purchase price, every month the apartment is owned. A buyer comparing a vintage co-op with a newer Gold Coast condo should line up the full monthly cost of each, not just the list prices. This post is general market information, not legal, tax or financial advice, and buyers should confirm any building's current charges and their own situation with the right professionals.

The same report gave a second reason so few co-ops have traded lately: affluent buyers' preference for new construction and modern design. Downtown condos as a group have also had trouble reaching the prices they traded at a few years ago, as buyer interest moved toward North Side neighborhoods and the suburbs, according to The Real Deal's November 2025 coverage. Both pressures make the vintage co-op buyer pool smaller. Neither one stopped these apartments from selling once the asking price reached the market.

The buyers were also still there at the top of the market. A 1920s Lake Shore Drive co-op penthouse, designed to look like a castle in the sky, sold for $7.7 million on August 19, 2024. Crain's Chicago Business reported that it was the second-highest home price in the Chicago area for 2024 up to that date. When the Farley unit went under contract in September 2025, The Real Deal noted that a sale near its $7.9 million ask would be the highest on the East Lake Shore Drive strip in at least six years. Lowe said in that report that interest in the apartment jumped after the summer price cut.

The 2026 listings will be judged against these numbers

Two co-ops reported for sale this year will show whether sellers have adjusted their first asking prices to the 2024 and 2025 closings.

In May, Crain's reported that a Gold Coast co-op owned by River North gallerist Maya Polsky was coming to market. The building is on East Lake Shore Drive. In October, Crain's covered an Astor Street co-op listed at $2.5 million. It is in a building completed in 1930, it is for sale for the first time in at least 30 years, and it includes fragments of one of Chicago's most opulent 19th-century homes.

The Astor Street listing's $2.5 million price is below even the lowest of the three trophy closings, a smaller apartment priced from the start near the level the market has set. Lowe's comment from last November fits both apartments. He said bigger recent deals downtown show buyer interest picking up, but units have to be priced to the market to sell. A buyer looking at either apartment, or at any vintage co-op on the Gold Coast, can compare its per-square-foot ask with the $450 to $625 range from the recent trophy closings and the $658 ask on the renovated Lurie unit. The monthly charge goes next to that number.

For owners, the takeaway from these sales applies whether the home is a co-op or a condo. Pricing to the market got these apartments sold, and price cuts made after the fact did not. Our guide to preparing and pricing a Gold Coast condo covers the seller side of the same decision.

Questions buyers ask about Gold Coast co-ops

Do vintage co-ops on East Lake Shore Drive still sell? Yes. Three closed between January 2024 and November 2025 at 1500 North Lake Shore Drive, 199 East Lake Shore Drive and 209 East Lake Shore Drive. A 1920s Lake Shore Drive penthouse also sold for $7.7 million in August 2024.

Should buyers expect the same half-off discount on a smaller unit? The deepest cuts were on apartments of 9,600 to 12,000 square feet. A renovated 5,700-square-foot unit at 209 East Lake Shore Drive was listed in March 2025 at $658 a square foot, more per foot than any of the three trophy sales closed at.

What does a co-op cost to carry each month? It depends on the building and the unit. The one published figure in this group is $14,330 a month for the Wrigley-family unit at 1500 North Lake Shore Drive when it sold in January 2024.

Jeff Lowe represented the seller at 209 East Lake Shore Drive, so this is a market we have priced from the listing side. If you are weighing a vintage co-op against a newer condo, or thinking about when to list one, Lowe Group Chicago can show you how comparable apartments have actually closed and what they cost to carry each month. Let's Connect.

Fifteen real estate team members pose together beneath Chicago and national rankings and a $4B sales figure. secondary

About the Author - The Lowe Group

The Lowe Group is a team of #1 Chicago real estate agents with strong broker and community ties. With our deep local knowledge and connections, we ensure that your home is priced right and receives maximum exposure. As seasoned negotiators and marketing experts, we are dedicated to providing a seamless and stress-free experience.

Work With Us

We are not just here to help sell or buy your home; we are here to be a valuable resource for all your home needs and questions. Passionate about real estate, we find joy in the industry's dynamic nature and the opportunity it presents to connect people with their dream homes. Our success is built on our local expertise and market knowledge.